Okay, I can't believe I'm even writing this, but here goes.
Even before I found out I was having twin girls, I had two girl names picked out. I was so certain these were the names, that I even had them embroidered on the Pottery Barn diaper bags I bought. I never wavered--I just knew they were the names.
When we went into the hospital, I decided it might be wise just to have a couple of names as backup--just in case we looked at the babies and the names we had chosen didn't fit. I took a short list with me, but didn't think I would use it.
After the girls were born, I wasn't able to see them until the next day. During this time, I fretted over one of the names I had planned to use all along. I knew without a doubt that Kate would be one of the names, but the other one, Caroline, I started doubting. Someone said something to me about the fact that they would always be called Carolyn (which, I don't care for), and added to the steady drip of morphine and discombobulated hormones I panicked. Why do we name children while in the hospital? Maybe it's just me, but making a life-long decision while under the influence may not be the best thing. :)
So, I named her Emma. Which for the record, wasn't even on my official short list. I had never in my life even considered actually using it as a name. I remember thinking about it, but not giving it much credence. Not that I don't like it, in fact, I think it's a beautiful name, it just wasn't one I thought I would use.
I did use Caroline as her middle name, because I still loved it so much I wanted it a part of her.
Ever since that day, I have regretted it. I thought about changing it back to Caroline right after she was born, and every 6 months or so I have seriously considered it. Every time I see or hear the name Caroline, it reminds me, and I wish that I used it. A couple of days ago, I had a conversation with a friend that started me thinking about it all over again. I don't know why I can't stop thinking about it. Was she "supposed" to be Emma" Or was I totally out-of-it and changed it wrongly? Logically, I know she can be either one, and it really doesn't make a huge difference, but I want it to feel right. I want to call her her name, and know it fits.
So, I'm at a crossroads. If I am going to change it, it has to be NOW. Like this week. She turned 2 a few months ago, but I think she's still young enough to have it work. I wouldn't want it any later than this though, and I'm tired of always thinking about it. I want to make a decision, and follow through with it. I actually call her Emma-Caroline most of the time, and she will answer to either name. Even Kate calls her that, and knows who I'm talking about when I do. For our family I don't think it would be a big deal, but with other people I'm thinking it may be difficult to do.
So, I need your help. I have a few options: 1) leave her name as Emma, 2) hyphenate her name and call her Emma-Caroline, 3) start calling her Caroline. Should I even consider it? Or have a I made my bed and need to live with it? I have gone back and forth for days, and now I really need some perspective. Please tell me your opinion, and the pros and cons you can think of. I need to make a decision and move on--and let her be who she is. So, what do you think--is she an Emma, Caroline, or Emma-Caroline?








Even before I found out I was having twin girls, I had two girl names picked out. I was so certain these were the names, that I even had them embroidered on the Pottery Barn diaper bags I bought. I never wavered--I just knew they were the names.
When we went into the hospital, I decided it might be wise just to have a couple of names as backup--just in case we looked at the babies and the names we had chosen didn't fit. I took a short list with me, but didn't think I would use it.
After the girls were born, I wasn't able to see them until the next day. During this time, I fretted over one of the names I had planned to use all along. I knew without a doubt that Kate would be one of the names, but the other one, Caroline, I started doubting. Someone said something to me about the fact that they would always be called Carolyn (which, I don't care for), and added to the steady drip of morphine and discombobulated hormones I panicked. Why do we name children while in the hospital? Maybe it's just me, but making a life-long decision while under the influence may not be the best thing. :)
So, I named her Emma. Which for the record, wasn't even on my official short list. I had never in my life even considered actually using it as a name. I remember thinking about it, but not giving it much credence. Not that I don't like it, in fact, I think it's a beautiful name, it just wasn't one I thought I would use.
I did use Caroline as her middle name, because I still loved it so much I wanted it a part of her.
Ever since that day, I have regretted it. I thought about changing it back to Caroline right after she was born, and every 6 months or so I have seriously considered it. Every time I see or hear the name Caroline, it reminds me, and I wish that I used it. A couple of days ago, I had a conversation with a friend that started me thinking about it all over again. I don't know why I can't stop thinking about it. Was she "supposed" to be Emma" Or was I totally out-of-it and changed it wrongly? Logically, I know she can be either one, and it really doesn't make a huge difference, but I want it to feel right. I want to call her her name, and know it fits.
So, I'm at a crossroads. If I am going to change it, it has to be NOW. Like this week. She turned 2 a few months ago, but I think she's still young enough to have it work. I wouldn't want it any later than this though, and I'm tired of always thinking about it. I want to make a decision, and follow through with it. I actually call her Emma-Caroline most of the time, and she will answer to either name. Even Kate calls her that, and knows who I'm talking about when I do. For our family I don't think it would be a big deal, but with other people I'm thinking it may be difficult to do.
So, I need your help. I have a few options: 1) leave her name as Emma, 2) hyphenate her name and call her Emma-Caroline, 3) start calling her Caroline. Should I even consider it? Or have a I made my bed and need to live with it? I have gone back and forth for days, and now I really need some perspective. Please tell me your opinion, and the pros and cons you can think of. I need to make a decision and move on--and let her be who she is. So, what do you think--is she an Emma, Caroline, or Emma-Caroline?